11 old toys that are worth way more than you think

Robots in Disguise Soundwave, Starscream and Skywarp
Flickr | Pete Slater

If you’re cleaning out your parents’ attic or going through boxes in the garage, you might want to wait before tossing any old toys in the donation bin. While chances are good most of the playthings from your past only hold sentimental value, there’s always the possibility that you’re hanging on to a treasure without even realizing it.

Check out some popular toys from the ’80s and ’90s that have fetched a pretty penny on eBay for their lucky owners.

1. My Little Pony

In 1981, Hasbro came out with a toy called “My Pretty Pony,” which shrunk and became “My Little Pony” the following year. Since then, there have been numerous pony generations, ranging from the first basic, brown horse to glittering, rainbow-laden unicorns. While most of the old MLP dolls are simply garage sale fodder, a small lot of first gen prototypes sold for $8,500.

my little pony toy photo
Flickr | Lisa Brewster

2. Hot Wheels

In 1966, an inventor, a rocket scientist and an automotive engineer collaborated on an idea for a new type of toy. More than 50 years later, kids still enjoy racing the affordable miniature hot rods. Who knew they could be valuable? Someone did, because a collection of Hot Wheels from the ’60s and ’70s sold on eBay for nearly $5,300.

hot wheels photo
Getty Images | Justin Sullivan

3. Lionel Train

Lionel produced its first electric train in 1901 and kids (as well as grownups) have enjoyed them ever since. So much so, in fact, that some of them are extremely valuable. A rare trolley recently sold for  $9,100.

lionel train photo
Flickr | Jim, the Photographer

4. Power Rangers

You would be hard pressed to find a ’90s kid who didn’t have a favorite  Power Ranger. Toy maker Bandai began creating Mighty Morphin toys in 1993, so if you’re stashing your old action figures somewhere, they likely produced it. Bandai also made a Zeo Zeonizer Morpher replica, one of which was sold for the high bid of $7,172.

mighty morphin power rangers photo
Flickr | France1978

5. Star Wars

You always knew your Star Wars toys would be worth big bucks one day, but your mom never believed you. Hopefully, she didn’t hand down your 1978 vintage Kenner Jawa to your cousin Billy, because one fetched $20,000 on eBay.

old star wars toy photo
Flickr | naz66

6. Pokemon

If you just had to catch them all, let’s hope you caught (and kept) a first edition Holo Charizard. Someone paid nearly $24,000 for the Pokemon card.

pokemon card photo
Flickr | Minhimalism

7. G.I. Joe

The military action figure hit the market in 1964. Since then, he’s been on countless missions and had starring roles in television and movies. Apparently, G.I. Joe has been making some people a bit wealthier, as well. A G.I. Joe Defiant Space Shuttle Launch Complex Vehicle sold for almost $5,000.

GI Joe action photo
Getty Images | Tim Boyle

8. Beanie Babies

Although they were not the treasure troves many collectors once thought they would be, there are a few Beanie Babies that were worth holding on to. For example, a bidder purchased a Princess Diana Beanie Baby for more than $3,000.

beanie babies photo
Flickr | Dominique Godbout

9. Transformers

Hasbro introduced Optimus Prime and other toy Autobots to the U.S. in 1984. The Transformers are still near and dear to the hearts of children and adults, and it shows in the popularity of the playthings. A die-cast first generation Transformers Hot Spot Protectobot Leader sold for more than $1,000.

transformers toys photo
Flickr | deltaMike

10. Spiderman

The amazing web-slinger swung onto the scene in 1962 and has enthralled children with his superhero skills ever since. Toys continue to be popular and can be valuable as well. A 1967 action figure netted more than $7,000.

spiderman figure photo
Flickr | Hannaford

11. Fisher-Price

Who didn’t have some sort of “Little People” playset? If you still have one in good condition, it could bring you some cool cash. A vintage 1974 Fisher-Price Play Family Castle sold on eBay for nearly $800.

fisher price little people photo
Flickr | rebeccanineill

Not every popular plaything from your younger years is valuable, but you never know. Perhaps your basement or your mom’s garage is holding a jackpot.

Curiosity, Entertainment, Money

About the Author
Tricia Goss
Tricia Goss is a Texas-based writer and editor with nearly two decades of experience. She is passionate about helping readers improve their skills, gain knowledge and attain more happiness in life. When she’s not working, Tricia enjoys traveling with her husband and their dog, especially to visit their five grandchildren.

From our partners