Buy Harry Potter butterbeer-flavored peanut butter

Nerdy Nuts

If you love all things Harry Potter and his drink of choice, butterbeer, there’s a new way to enjoy the flavor and bring some magic to your muggle meals — butterbeer-flavored peanut butter!

According to small-batch peanut-butter maker Nerdy Nuts, butterbeer peanut butter has “slivers of butter rum toffee mixed with sweet, thick butterscotch.” While it sounds like it would be great on morning toast or a sandwich, it may also be the perfect replacement in any recipe that calls for peanut butter, like these peanut butter cheesecake truffles.

Nerdy Nuts says the peanut butter is so popular that it sells out quickly once it’s restocked, but they are adding tens of thousands of jars every Sunday, so you should be able to get your hands on some if you keep an eye on their website. A 16-ounce jar is $12.99.

Nerdy Nuts


If you want to add some other flavors to your order or just try something else, Nerdy Nuts has tons of fun peanut butter flavors, including cookies & screamwhite chocolate, monster cookie and fluffernutter.

The fluffernutter flavor combines the flavors from a favorite sandwich from childhood: Sweet and fluffy marshmallow cream is hand-mixed with Nerdy Nuts’ freshly-ground, honey-roasted peanut butter, all in one jar.

Nerdy Nuts

Plenty of other companies have created butterbeer-inspired treats, too.

Butterbeer marshmallows, for example, are butterscotch-flavored marshmallows that have a hint of cinnamon, cream and vanilla. While liquor is used in the making of the marshmallows, it is burned off in the process, so they are alcohol-free.

You can also find butterbeer ice cream from Yuengling’s Ice Cream, based in Pennsylvania. Made using half buttercream ice cream and half butterscotch ice cream, it can be found at specialty grocery stores and some chain stores around the country.

Yuengling’s Ice Cream

You can even make your own Harry Potter-inspired recipes at home, including butterbeer cookies and hot chocolate. You can even order a hot butterbeer Latte from Starbucks’ “secret” menu.

The latte is made with whole milk and toffee nut, caramel and cinnamon dolce syrups. You can also include espresso if you want some caffeine. It is then garnished with whipped cream and salted caramel pieces or the caramel brûlée topping.

Virus Outbreak California
AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli

Are you a fan of butterbeer-flavored treats?

Entertainment, Food, Movies & TV, Music, News
, , ,

Related posts

Cheetos Crunchy Buffalo
New Crunchy Buffalo Cheetos flavor celebrates the Super Bowl
Universal Epic Universe concept art
Universal's new Epic Universe theme park appears to live up to its name
Betty Crocker's new Oreo baking kit
Betty Crocker has a new line of Oreo baking mixes, plus frosting
A package of new Oreo Space Dunk cookies floating in space.
Oreo is offering a new out-of-this-world flavor and a chance to go into space

About the Author
Kaitlin Gates
Kaitlin is a freelance multimedia journalist with a degree in journalism and psychology. Along with Simplemost, she also writes for Don't Waste Your Money, where she loves finding great deals to help people save money.

From our partners