Which ice cream brand has the most cookie dough?


Ice cream is awesome. Cookie dough is awesome. Cookie dough ice cream might possibly be humankind’s greatest invention.

But not all cookie dough ice cream is created equal. So Buzzfeed — in what is surely the highest calling of the scientific method — decided to conduct an experiment to find out which brand of ice cream offers the most cookie-dough bang for your buck.

The four brands Buzzfeed tested were Ben and Jerry’s, Haagen-Dazs, SO Delicious and Three Twins. Someone with way more willpower than me scooped out the ice cream into a bowl and waited for it to melt and — WHY ARE YOU DOING THIS SAVE THE ICE CREAM! NOOOOO!

Once the ice cream was melted, testers could separate out the cookie dough and weigh it.

And The Cookie Dough Winner Is?

Ben and Jerry’s clearly won the cookie crown. It contained almost 3.5 ounces of cookie dough, accounting for 21 percent of the total pint. Haagen Daas came in second with 2 ounces, followed by SO Delicious and Three Twins, each with 1.25 ounces.

While this was a worthy experiment, I do see some areas in which further testing is necessary. Are the amounts consistent across all pints, or do some Ben & Jerry’s pints end up with more dough than others? Are the dough chunks spread evenly throughout the ice cream? What about which one has the highest concentration of chocolate chips? What about other lesser-known brands?

Basically what I am saying is you should just go to the store today and buy a whole bunch of cookie dough ice cream and do your own research. In the name of science. Maybe you can find a way to do the experiment without wasting the ice cream.

Of course, if you still aren’t satisfied with the amount of dough in your ice cream, there is a shop in New York that simply scoops out cookie dough into your cone. No ice cream needed.

I may not be a math major, but 100 percent seems like a very good cookie-dough ratio to me.


Related posts

Chocolate chip cookie dough portioned on pan
You can get a whole case of 144 ready-to-bake cookies at Sam's Club
Entenmann's ready-to-bake cookie dough and cookies on tray
You can now get ready-to-bake Entenmann's cookie dough
Left: cottage cheese cookie dough. Right: Jake Cohen.
Cottage cheese cookie dough is an easy, protein-packed treat
Sonic Drive-In's new Fried Cookie Dough Bites come with a small ice cream for dipping.
Sonic's new Fried Cookie Dough Bites come with a cup of ice cream for dipping

About the Author
Mitchell Byars
Mitchell Byars was born and raised in Hawaii and currently lives in Boulder, Colorado, where he is a reporter. On his free time, he likes to golf, swim and enjoy a nice beer.

From our partners